基于数据挖掘的慢性疲劳综合征动物模型的评价
作者单位:

1.河南中医药大学;2.河南中医药大学 药学院

基金项目:

国家自然科学基金(82274119);河南省重大专项(221100310400);岐黄学者(国中医药人教函2022-6);中原学者工作站项目(224400510011);2022年河南省博士后科研资助项目(HN2022079)


Evaluation of an animal model of chronic fatigue syndrome based on data mining
Author:
Affiliation:

1.Henan University of Chinese Medicine;2.Henan University of Chinese Medicine,Zhengzhou

  • 摘要
  • | |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献 [76]
  • | | | |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    目的:研究慢性疲劳综合征动物模型的应用情况,为其动物实验方法和模型完善提供参考。方法:以“慢性疲劳综合征,动物模型”“Chronic fatigue syndrom,animal model”等为检索词,在中国知网、万方、PubMed数据库进行检索,整理2000年7月至2023年7月慢性疲劳综合征动物模型的文献,对实验动物、造模方法、阳性药、检测指标等内容进行整理,建立数据库进行统计、分析。结果:共纳入有效文献155篇;实验动物以SPF级、周龄为6-8周的雄性SD大鼠最多,体重集中在180-220g;小鼠应用最多的是18-22g、周龄为6-8周的雄性KM小鼠;应用最多的阳性药是人参皂苷片;应用最多的造模方法是“强制冷水游泳+慢性束缚”法,造模周期多集中在14天,大多采用边造模边干预的方式;检测指标以行为学为主,主要包括力竭游泳实验、旷场实验、鼠尾悬吊实验、Morris水迷宫实验以及动物一般状态观察,其次是血清生化指标,检测最多的是血清MDA、SOD、TNF-α、IL-1β、CORT、IL-2、IFN-γ、ACTH、GSH-Px、IgG、IgA、IL-6等;根据研究目的不同选择其余多种检测指标,包括脾脏、胸腺等脏器指数测定、HE病理染色和超微结构电镜检测的形态学指标、免疫组化相关指标、时荧光定量PCR检测法检测的CRH、Smad4、BDNF、CREB、IFN-γ、NRF-1、TFAM、Tlr4等的相关mRNA表达指标,Western blot法检测的BDNF、CREB、ERK、Bmal1、Clock、NGF、PGC-1α、SIRT1、Smad4、Caspsae-3等的相关蛋白表达指标。结论:目前慢性疲劳综合征的发病机制尚不明确,动物模型以“强制冷水游泳+慢性束缚”的应激造模方法为主,模拟人类身体和心理疲劳状态;动物模型成模标准尚无统一规定,模型评价方式以各种行为学实验单独或组合应用为主,多数文献中客观评价指标多用于病因病机猜想的论证及干预措施有效性评价;各项检测指标应用结果表明慢性疲劳综合征可能与炎症反应、神经功能障碍和线粒体功能异常等因素有关,其发病机制中可能存在免疫功能、能量代谢、细胞增殖和细胞死亡的异常状况,挖掘内容有望为模型应用提供参考,为模型完善提供思路。

    Abstract:

    Objective To study the application of the animal model of chronic fatigue syndrome, and to provide reference for its animal experimental methods and model improvement. Methods Using "chronic fatigue syndrome, animal model" and "chronic fatigue syndrom, animal model" as search terms, we searched in China Knowledge, Wanfang and PubMed databases. Literature on animal models of chronic fatigue syndrome was compiled from July 2000 to July 2023, and experimental animals, modeling methods, positive drugs, and detection indexes were sorted out, and a database was established for statistics and analysis. Results A total of 155 articles were included; the most experimental animals were male SD rats of SPF grade and 6-8 weeks of age, with weights of 180-220g; the most used mice were male KM mice of 18-22g and 6-8 weeks of age; the most used positive drug was ginseng saponin tablets; the most used modeling method was the method of "forced cold water swimming + chronic restraint"; the most used modeling method was the method of "forced cold water swimming + chronic restraint"; the most used modeling method was the method of "forced cold water swimming + chronic restraint". +The most widely used modeling method is the "forced cold water swimming" method, and the modeling cycle is mostly concentrated in 14 days, and most of them adopt the method of intervention while modeling; the testing indexes are mainly behavioral, which mainly include the exhaustion swimming experiment, the open field experiment, the rat-tail suspension experiment, the Morris water maze experiment, and the observation of the general state of the animals, and the second is the serum biochemical indexes, and the most frequently detected indexes are serum MDA, SOD, TNF-alpha, IOD, and IBP, TNF-α, IL-1β, CORT, IL-2, IFN-γ, ACTH, GSH-Px, IgG, IgA, IL-6, etc. The rest of the indicators were selected according to the research purpose, including the indexes of spleen, thymus, etc., the morphological indicators detected by HE staining and ultrastructural electron microscopy, the immunohistochemistry-related indicators, the CRH and Smilax detected by fluorescence PCR, the CRH, the Smilax, the Smilax, and the Smilax. The mRNA expression indexes of CRH, Smad4, BDNF, CREB, IFN-γ, NRF-1, TFAM, Tlr4, etc., and the protein expression indexes of BDNF, CREB, ERK, Bmal1, Clock, NGF, PGC-1α, SIRT1, Smad4, Caspsae-3, etc., were determined by Western blot method. and other related protein expression indicators. Conclusion At present, the pathogenesis of chronic fatigue syndrome is still unclear, and the animal model is mainly based on the stress modeling method of "forced cold water swimming + chronic restraint", which simulates the physical and mental fatigue state of human beings; there is no uniform regulation on the criteria for the formation of animal models, and the evaluation of the model is based on the application of a variety of behavioral experiments individually or in combination, and the objective evaluation indexes are mostly used to argue the etiology of the disease and evaluate the effectiveness of interventions. The objective evaluation indexes are mostly used to prove the conjecture of etiology and evaluate the effectiveness of interventions; the results of the application of various test indexes show that chronic fatigue syndrome may be related to inflammatory response, neurological dysfunction, and mitochondrial dysfunction, and there may be abnormalities in the pathogenesis of immune function, energy metabolism, cell proliferation, and cell death, which is expected to provide reference for the application of the model, and to provide ideas for the model"s refinement. The excavated content is expected to provide reference for the application of the model and provide ideas for the improvement of the model.

    参考文献
    [1] 成泽东,陈以国,张涛.温和灸对慢性疲劳大鼠肠道菌群的影响[J].中国中医药信息杂志,2013,20(01):45-46+63.
    Cheng Z D,Chen Y G,Zhang T. Effects of gentle moxibustion on intestinal flora in rats with chronic fatigue[J]. China Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Information,2013,20(01):45-46+63.
    [3] [2]张力,张强,刘凯利,等.中医辨证分型治疗慢性疲劳综合征的临床研究进展[J].现代中西医结合杂志,2022,31(18):2623-2628.
    Zhang L,Zhang Q,Liu K L,et al. Progress of clinical research on the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome by identification and typing in traditional Chinese medicine[J]. Modern Journal of Integrative Medicine,2022,31(18):2623-2628.
    [5] [3]李悦,韩秀珍,徐秋露,等.慢性疲劳综合征动物模型的构建与评价[J].中国实验方剂学杂志,2023,29(09):234-242.
    Li Y, Han X Z, Xu Q L, et al. Construction and evaluation of an animal model of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Chinese Journal of Experimental Pharmacy,2023,29(09):234-242.
    [7] [4]Strassheim V, Newton J L, Collins T. Experiences of Living with Severe Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalomyelitis[J]. Healthcare (Basel),2021,9(2):168.
    [8] [5]水玲,乌云格日乐,卢峻,等.蒙医温针对慢性疲劳大鼠iNOS信号通路及海马、下丘脑细胞因子表达的影响[J].辽宁中医杂志,2021,48(09):196-198.
    Shui Li,Uyun G R L,Lu J,et al. Effects of Mongolian warming on iNOS signaling pathway and cytokine expression in hippocampus and hypothalamus of rats with chronic fatigue[J]. Liaoning Journal of Chinese Medicine,2021,48(09):196-198.
    [10] [6]Lorusso L, Mikhaylova S V, Capelli E, et al.Immunological aspects of chronic fatigue syndrome[J].Autoimmun Rev, 2009, 8 (4) :287-291.
    [11] [7]李娜,王洁晶,陈晓敏,等.慢性疲劳综合征的中医研究进展[J].中国中医药现代远程教育,2023,21(09):200-202.
    Li N,Wang J J,Chen X M,et al. Progress of Chinese medicine research on chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. China Traditional Chinese Medicine Modern Distance Education,2023,21(09):200-202.
    [13] [8]韩雪,李京,刘文华,等.中医适宜技术干预慢性疲劳综合征临床研究概况[J].光明中医,2022,37(19):3629-3631.
    Han X,Li J,Liu W H,et al. Overview of clinical research on Chinese medicine appropriate technology intervention for chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Bright Chinese Medicine,2022,37(19):3629-3631.
    [15] [9]陶睿智,顾任钧,夏雅雯,等.功能性消化不良动物模型的研究进展[J].中国实验动物学报,2022,30(02):283-290.
    Tao R Z, Gu R J, Xia Y W, et al. Research progress of functional dyspepsia animal model[J]. Chinese Journal of Laboratory Animals,2022,30(02):283-290.
    [17] [10]刘昊,李文静,王馨嫒,等.基于数据挖掘的功能性消化不良动物模型的评价[J].中国实验动物学报,2023,31(04):478-491.
    Liu H, Li W J, Wang X Y, et al. Evaluation of a functional dyspepsia animal model based on data mining[J]. Chinese Journal of Laboratory Animals,2023,31(04):478-491.
    [19] [11]邓亚胜,黄慧,梁天薇,等.基于数据挖掘的慢性支气管炎动物模型应用分析[J].中国实验动物学报,2023,31(03):327-336.
    Deng Y S,Huang H,Liang TW,et al. Application analysis of chronic bronchitis animal model based on data mining[J]. Chinese Journal of Laboratory Animals,2023,31(03):327-336.
    [21] [12]封艳艳,蔡尚志,何江山,等.针刺对慢性疲劳模型大鼠海马TLR4/NF-κB信号通路及星形胶质细胞的影响[J].针灸临床杂志,2023,39(02):68-74.
    Feng Y Y,Cai S Z,He J S,et al. Effects of acupuncture on hippocampal TLR4/NF-κB signaling pathway and astrocytes in rats with chronic fatigue model[J]. Acupuncture Clinical Journal,2023,39(02):68-74.
    [23] [13]钟晓玲,童伯瑛,杨一涵,等.经皮穴位电刺激对慢性疲劳综合征大鼠学习记忆能力的影响及其机制探讨[J].针刺研究,2023,48(04):317-324.
    Zhong X L,Tong BY,Yang YH,et al. Effects of transcutaneous electrical stimulation of acupoints on learning memory ability and its mechanism in rats with chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Acupuncture Research,2023,48(04):317-324.
    [25] [14]武淑娟,张青川,何采辉,等.电针对复合应激致慢性疲劳大鼠下丘脑组织中单胺类神经递质含量的影响[J].针刺研究,2006(02):96-99.
    Wu SJ,Zhang QC,He CH,et al. Effects of electroacupuncture on the content of monoamine neurotransmitters in the hypothalamus tissue of rats chronically fatigued by compound stress[J]. Acupuncture Research,2006(02):96-99.
    [27] [15]郑娟娟,赵毅,姚斐.慢性疲劳综合征的动物造模方法研究概况[J].时珍国医国药,2009,20(09):2289-2291.
    Zheng JJ,Zhao Y,Yao F. Overview of animal modeling methods for chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Shizhen Guojian,2009,20(09):2289-2291.
    [29] [16]牛占忠,刘丁丁,岳雁,等.补肾疏肝汤对慢性疲劳综合征大鼠模型抗疲劳作用机制的实验研究[J].河北中医,2020,42(01):96-100+131.
    Niu ZZ,Liu DD,Yue Y,et al. Experimental study on the mechanism of anti-fatigue effect of tonifying kidney and sparing liver soup on rat model of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Hebei Traditional Chinese Medicine,2020,42(01):96-100+131.
    [31] [17]牛占忠,张喜平,周红军,等.补肾疏肝汤对大鼠抗疲劳作用的机理[J].河南中医,2015,35(09):2047-2048.
    Niu ZZ,Zhang XP,ZHOU Hou HJ,et al. Mechanism of anti-fatigue effect of tonifying kidney and sparing liver soup on rats[J]. Henan Traditional Chinese Medicine,2015,35(09):2047-2048.
    [33] [18]Bassett S A , Young W , Fraser K , et al. Metabolome and microbiome profiling of a stress-sensitive rat model of gut-brain axis dysfunction [J].Sci Rep,2019,9( 1) : 14026.
    [34] [19]王向义,刘长征,雷波.针刺对慢性疲劳综合征大鼠血浆T细胞转录因子/GATA结合蛋白3表达的影响[J].针刺研究,2017,42(03):246-248+262.
    Wang XY,Liu CZ,Lei B. Effect of acupuncture on the expression of plasma T cell transcription factor/GATA binding protein 3 in rats with chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Acupuncture Research,2017,42(03):246-248+262.
    [36] [20]韩玲,颜志浪,刘长征.安神定志方对慢性疲劳综合征大鼠色氨酸代谢通路及运动能力的影响[J].中成药,2021,43(12):3493-3497.
    Han L,Yan ZL,Liu CZ. Effects of Anshen Dingzhi Fang on tryptophan metabolic pathway and exercise capacity in rats with chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Chinese patent medicine,2021,43(12):3493-3497.
    [38] [21]董林林.清暑益气汤治疗脾虚湿热型慢性疲劳综合征的临床观察[J].中国民间疗法,2020,28(20):72-74.
    Dong LL. Clinical observation on the treatment of spleen deficiency and dampness-heat type chronic fatigue syndrome with clear summer heat and benefit qi soup[J]. Chinese folk therapy,2020,28(20):72-74.
    [40] [22]石世德,周民伟,李建军,等.慢性应激性疲劳小鼠行为和神经内分泌改变与怡欣乐口服液的干预作用(英文)[J].中国临床康复,2005(36):179-181.
    Shi SD,Zhou MW,Li JJ,et al. Behavioral and neuroendocrine changes in chronic stress fatigue mice and the intervention effect of Yixinle oral solution(In English)[J]. China Clinical Rehabilitation,2005(36):179-181.
    [42] [23]周翠兰,孙翠梅,王莹,等.心神安胶囊治疗慢性疲劳综合征的效果观察及对外周血NK细胞活性、T淋巴细胞亚群的影响[J].湖南师范大学学报(医学版),2022,19(03):53-57.
    ZHOU Cuilan,SUN Cuimei,WANG Ying,et al. Observation on the effect of Xin Shen An capsule in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome and its influence on peripheral blood NK cell activity and T lymphocyte subpopulation[J]. Journal of Hunan Normal University (Medical Edition),2022,19(03):53-57.
    [44] [24]陈虹. 复方红景天片质量标准及功能活性研究[D].天津科技大学,2014.
    CHEN Hong. Research on quality standard and functional activity of Compound Rhodiola rosea tablets[D]. Tianjin University of Science and Technology,2014.
    [46] [25]李欢,侯江红,许瑾,等.重灸足三里联合盐酸帕罗西汀片治疗慢性疲劳综合症患者的疗效观察[J].中国中西医结合杂志,2020,40(03):371-373.
    LI Huan,HOU Jianghong,XU Jin,et al. Observations on the efficacy of heavy moxibustion foot Sanli combined with paroxetine hydrochloride tablets in treating patients with chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine,2020,40(03):371-373.
    [48] [26]张彦中.针刺联合逍遥丸治疗肝郁脾虚型慢性疲劳综合征临床效果观察[J].包头医学院学报,2021,37(03):115-118.
    Zhang Yanzhong. Clinical effect observation of acupuncture combined with prolongation pill in treating chronic fatigue syndrome of liver depression and spleen deficiency type[J]. Journal of Baotou Medical College,2021,37(03):115-118.
    [50] [27]张烨.中药复方对慢性疲劳大鼠认知能力及下丘脑生物钟基因表达的影响[J].时珍国医国药,2022,33(07):1579-1581.
    Zhang Ye. Effects of traditional Chinese medicine compound on cognitive ability and hypothalamic biological clock gene expression in rats with chronic fatigue[J]. Shizhen Guomian Guomian,2022,33(07):1579-1581.
    [52] [28]刘伟成,黎杰轩,郭永宁,等.炙甘草汤对慢性疲劳综合征大鼠行为和4种白介素水平的影响[J].动物医学进展,2018,39(07):70-73.
    LIU Weicheng,LI Jiexuan,GUO Yongning,et al. Effects of roasted licorice soup on behavior and levels of 4 interleukins in rats with chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Advances in Animal Medicine,2018,39(07):70-73.
    [54] [29]王玉琳,刘同岩,孙玮,等.慢性疲劳综合征动物模型评价方式的现状与思考[J].医学综述,2022,28(14):2884-2888.
    WANG Yulin,LIU Tongyan,SUN Wei,et al. Current status and thoughts on the evaluation of animal models of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Medical Review,2022,28(14):2884-2888.
    [56] [30]徐小珊,田岳凤,翟春涛,等.慢性疲劳综合征大鼠模型的行为学特征研究[J].中西医结合心脑血管病杂志,2022,20(21):3906-3912.
    XU Xiaoshan,TIAN Yuefeng,ZHAI Chuntao,et al. Behavioral characteristics of a rat model of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Journal of Cardiovascular and Cerebrovascular Diseases in Chinese and Western Medicine,2022,20(21):3906-3912.
    [58] [31]王庆勇,孙维伯,杨燕,等.慢性疲劳综合征常用动物模型研究进展[J].神经损伤与功能重建,2021,16(07):392-394+413.
    WANG Qingyong,SUN Weibe,YANG Yan,et al. Progress of research on commonly used animal models of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Neurological Injury and Functional Reconstruction,2021,16(07):392-394+413.
    [60] [32]Bethan J,Corin B,Peter G. Evaluating the ability of patient reported outcome measures to represent the functional limitation of people living with myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. Fatigue: Biomedicine, Health & Behavior,2023,11(2-4).
    [61] [33]Nicola B C,Sarah T,Karen L, et al. Home-based testing protocol to measure physiological responses to everyday activities in ME: a feasibility study[J]. Fatigue: Biomedicine, Health & Behavior,2023,11(2-4).
    [62] [34]Eide M G,Tormod L. Characteristics associated with physical functioning and fatigue in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS): secondary analyses of a randomized controlled trial[J]. Fatigue: Biomedicine, Health & Behavior,2023,11(2-4).
    [63] [35]王虎,张姣姣,孙俊楠,等.白介素-6联合CD4~+T淋巴细胞百分比对脓毒症患者预后的评估价值[J].内科理论与实践,2021,16(06):404-408.
    WANG Hu,ZHANG Jiaojiao,SUN Junnan,et al. The value of interleukin-6 combined with CD4~+ T lymphocyte percentage in assessing the prognosis of patients with sepsis[J]. Internal Medicine Theory and Practice,2021,16(06):404-408.
    [65] [36]李志超,曹庆生,曹俊杰.矮地茶黄酮对大鼠急性酒精性肝损伤的保护作用研究[J].贵州中医药大学学报,2021,43(01):24-28.
    LI Zhichao,CAO Qingsheng,CAO Junjie. Study on the protective effect of Chondrus crispus flavonoids on acute alcoholic liver injury in rats[J]. Journal of Guizhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine,2021,43(01):24-28.
    [67] [37]黄熙龙,费书珂.中性粒细胞胞外诱捕网的形成机制及其与肝胆胰炎症性疾病的联系[J].现代免疫学,2022,42(04):364-368.
    HUANG Xi-Long,FEI Shu-Ke. Mechanism of neutrophil extracellular trap network formation and its association with hepatobiliary and pancreatic inflammatory diseases[J]. Modern Immunology,2022,42(04):364-368.
    [69] [38]张超,张锐,王冶,等.大豆皂苷缓解骨关节炎模型大鼠软骨损伤和关节炎症的机制[J].免疫学杂志,2023,39(03):225-232.
    ZHANG Chao,ZHANG Rui,WANG Ye,et al. Mechanism of soybean saponin in alleviating cartilage damage and joint inflammation in rats with osteoarthritis model[J]. Journal of Immunology,2023,39(03):225-232.
    [71] [39]Mariangela R,Antonella R,Giovanna P, et al. Two-month period of 500 mg lecithin-based delivery form of quercetin daily dietary supplementation counterbalances chronic fatigue symptoms: A double-blind placebo controlled clinical trial.[J]. Biomedicine & pharmacotherapy = Biomedecine & pharmacotherapie,2023,167.
    [72] [40]Dias T D,Jo?o M,D.Association analysis between symptomology and herpesvirus IgG antibody concentrations in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) and multiple sclerosis[J]. Heliyon,2023,9(7).
    [73] [41]赵云,张苗苗,金杰.中医药治疗慢性疲劳综合征研究进展[J].中国现代应用药学,2023,40(11):1571-1577.
    ZHAO Yun,ZHANG Miao Miao,JIN Jie. Research progress of traditional Chinese medicine in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome[J]. China Modern Applied Pharmacy,2023,40(11):1571-1577.
    [75] [42]Jessica B,Monica R,Marcela R, et al. Clinical and Biomarker Profile Responses to Rehabilitation Treatment in Patients with Long COVID Characterized by Chronic Fatigue.[J]. Viruses,2023,15(7).
    [76] [43]Irene S,Sabine G,Maria D, et al. Circulating miRNAs Expression in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.[J]. International journal of molecular sciences,2023,24(13).
    相似文献
    引证文献
    网友评论
    网友评论
    分享到微博
    发 布
引用本文
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:312
  • 下载次数: 0
  • HTML阅读次数: 0
  • 引用次数: 0
历史
  • 收稿日期:2023-10-04
  • 最后修改日期:2024-03-04
  • 录用日期:2024-03-21
防诈骗提示!请勿点击不明链接或添加个人微信。编辑部所有邮箱后缀均为@cnilas.org
关闭